| DATE | SCORE | MVP | VENUE | LOCATION |
| Thu Feb 20 2025 | Canada 3, USA 2 (OT) | Nathan McKinnon, Canada | TD Garden | Boston, MA |
| Mon Feb 17 2025 | Canada 5, Finland 3 | |||
| Mon Feb 17 2025 | Sweden 2, USA 1 | |||
| Sat Feb 15 2025 | Finland 4, Sweden 3 (OT) | Bell Centre | Montreal, QC | |
| Sat Feb 15 2025 | USA 3, Canada 1 | |||
| Thu Feb 13 2025 | USA 6, Finland 1 | |||
| Wed Feb 12 2025 | Canada 4, Sweden 3 (OT) | |||
| Sat Feb 3 2024 | Team Matthews 6, Team McDavid 4 | Auston Matthews, Tor | Scotiabank Arena | Toronto, ON |
| Sat Feb 3 2024 | Team Matthews 6, Team Hughes 5 (SO) | |||
| Sat Feb 3 2024 | Team McDavid 4, Team MacKinnon 3 (SO) | |||
| Sat Feb 4 2023 | Atlantic 7, Central 5 | Matthew Tkachuk, Fla | FLA Live Arena | Sunrise, FL |
| Sat Feb 4 2023 | Atlantic 10, Metro 6 | |||
| Sat Feb 4 2023 | Central 6, Pacific 4 | |||
| Sat Feb 5 2022 | Metro 5, Central 3 | Claude Giroux, Phi | T-Mobile Arena | Las Vegas, NV |
| Sat Feb 5 2022 | Metro 6, Pacific 4 | |||
| Sat Feb 5 2022 | Central 8, Atlantic 5 | |||
| Sat Jan 25 2020 | Pacific 5, Atlantic 4 | David Pastrnak, Bos | Enterprise Center | St Louis, MO |
| Sat Jan 25 2020 | Pacific 10, Central 5 | |||
| Sat Jan 25 2020 | Atlantic 9, Metro 5 | |||
| Sat Jan 26 2019 | Metro 10, Central 5 | Sidney Crosby, Pit | SAP Center at San Jose | San Jose, CA |
| Sat Jan 26 2019 | Metro 7, Atlantic 4 | |||
| Sat Jan 26 2019 | Central 10, Pacific 4 | |||
| Sun Jan 28 2018 | Pacific 5, Atlantic 2 | Brock Boeser, Van | Amalie Arena | Tampa, FL |
| Sun Jan 28 2018 | Atlantic 7, Metro 4 | |||
| Sun Jan 28 2018 | Pacific 5, Central 2 | |||
| Sun Jan 29 2017 | Metro 4, Pacific 3 | Wayne Simmonds, Phi | Staples Center | Los Angeles, CA |
| Sun Jan 29 2017 | Metro 10, Atlantic 6 | |||
| Sun Jan 29 2017 | Pacific 10, Central 3 | |||
| Sun Jan 31 2016 | Pacific 1, Atlantic 0 | John Scott, Mtl | Bridgestone Arena | Nashville, TN |
| Sun Jan 31 2016 | Pacific 9, Central 6 | |||
| Sun Jan 31 2016 | Atlantic 4, Metro 3 | |||
| Sun Jan 25 2015 | Team Toews 17, Team Foligno 12 | Ryan Johansen, Cbs | Nationwide Arena | Columbus, OH |
| Sun Jan 29 2012 | Team Chara 12, Team Alfredsson 9 | Marian Gaborik, NYR | Scotiabank Place | Ottawa, Ont |
| Sun Jan 30 2011 | Team Lidstrom 11, Team Staal 10 | Patrick Sharp, Chi | RBC Center | Raleigh, NC |
| Sun Jan 25 2009 | East 12, West 11 (SO) | Alex Kovalev, Mtl | Bell Centre | Montreal, Que |
| Sun Jan 27 2008 | East 8, West 7 | Eric Staal, Car | Philips Arena | Atlanta, GA |
| Wed Jan 24 2007 | West 12, East 9 | Daniel Briere, Buf | American Airlines Center | Dallas, TX |
| Sun Feb 8 2004 | East 6, West 4 | Joe Sakic, Col | Xcel Energy Center | St Paul, MN |
| Sun Feb 2 2003 | West 6, East 5 (SO) | Dany Heatley, Atl | Office Depot Center | Sunrise, FL |
| Sat Feb 2 2002 | World 8, N. America 5 | Eric Daze, Chi | Staples Center | Los Angeles, CA |
| Sun Feb 4 2001 | N. America 14, World 12 | Bill Guerin, Bos | Pepsi Center | Denver, CO |
| Sun Jan 24 2000 | World 9, N. America 4 | Pavel Bure, Fla | Air Canada Centre | Toronto, Ont |
| Sun Jan 24 1999 | N. America 8, World 6 | Wayne Gretzky, NYR | Ice Palace | Tampa, FL |
| Sun Jan 18 1998 | N. America 8, World 7 | Teemu Selanne, Ana | General Motors Place | Vancouver, BC |
| Sat Jan 18 1997 | East 11, West 7 | Mark Recchi, Mtl | San Jose Arena | San Jose, CA |
| Sat Jan 20 1996 | East 5, West 4 | Ray Bourque, Bos | Fleet Center | Boston, MA |
| Sat Jan 22 1994 | East 9, West 8 | Mike Richter, NYR | Madison Square Garden | New York City, NY |
| Sat Feb 6 1993 | Wales 16, Campbell 6 | Mike Gartner, Mtl | Montreal Forum | Montreal, Que |
| Sat Jan 18 1992 | Campbell 10, Wales 6 | Brett Hull, StL | Spectrum | Philadelphia, PA |
| Sat Jan 19 1991 | Campbell 11, Wales 5 | Vincent Damphousse, Tor | Chicago Stadium | Chicago, IL |
| Sun Jan 21 1990 | Wales 12, Campbell 7 | Mario Lemieux, Pit | Civic Arena | Pittsburgh, PA |
| Tue Feb 7 1989 | Campbell 9, Wales 5 | Wayne Gretzky, LA | Northlands Coliseum | Edmonton, Alb |
| Tue Feb 9 1988 | Wales 6, Campbell 5 (OT) | Mario Lemieux, Pit | The St Louis Arena | St Louis, MO |
| Tue Feb 4 1986 | Wales 4, Campbell 3 (OT) | Grant Fuhr, Edm | Hartford Civic Center Col | Hartford, CT |
| Tue Feb 12 1985 | Wales 6, Campbell 4 | Mario Lemieux, Pit | Olympic Saddledome | Calgary, Alb |
| Tue Jan 31 1984 | Wales 7, Campbell 6 | Don Maloney, NYR | Brendan Byrne Arena | East Rutherford, NJ |
| Tue Feb 8 1983 | Campbell 9, Wales 3 | Wayne Gretzky, Edm | Nassau Coliseum | Uniondale, NY |
| Tue Feb 9 1982 | Wales 4, Campbell 2 | Mike Bossy, NYI | Capital Centre | Washington, DC |
| Tue Feb 10 1981 | Campbell 4, Wales 1 | Mike Liut, StL | Great Western Forum | Los Angeles, CA |
| Tue Feb 5 1980 | Wales 6, Campbell 3 | Reggie Leach, Phi | Joe Louis Arena | Detroit, MI |
| Tue Jan 24 1978 | Wales 3, Campbell 2 (OT) | Billy Smith, NYI | Buffalo Memorial Auditorium | Buffalo, NY |
| Tue Feb 13 1977 | Wales 4, Campbell 3 | Rick Martin, Buf | Pacific Coliseum | Vancouver, BC |
| Tue Jan 20 1976 | Wales 7, Campbell 5 | Peter Mahovlich, Mtl | Spectrum | Philadelphia, PA |
| Tue Jan 21 1975 | Wales 7, Campbell 1 | Syl Apps, Jr., Pit | Montreal Forum | Montreal, Que |
| Tue Jan 29 1974 | West 6, East 4 | Garry Unger, StL | Chicago Stadium | Chicago, IL |
| Tue Jan 30 1973 | East 5, West 4 | Greg Polis, Pit | Madison Square Garden | New York City, NY |
| Tue Jan 25 1972 | East 3, West 2 | Bobby Orr, Bos | Metropolitan Sports Center | Minneapolis, MN |
| Tue Jan 19 1971 | West 2, East 1 | Bobby Hull, Chi | Boston Garden | Boston, MA |
| Tue Jan 20 1970 | East 4, West 1 | Bobby Hull, Chi | The St Louis Arena | St Louis, MO |
| Tue Jan 21 1969 | West 3, East 3 (tie) | Frank Mahovlich, Det | Montreal Forum | Montreal, Que |
| Tue Jan 16 1968 | Toronto 4, All-Stars 3 | Bruce Gamble, Tor | Maple Leaf Gardens | Toronto, Ont |
| Wed Jan 18 1967 | Montreal 3, All-Stars 0 | Henri Richard, Mtl | Montreal Forum | Montreal, Que |
| Wed Oct 20 1965 | All-Stars 5, Montreal 2 | Gordie Howe, Det | Montreal Forum | Montreal, Que |
| Sat Oct 10 1964 | All-Stars 3, Toronto 2 | Jean Beliveau, Mtl | Maple Leaf Gardens | Toronto, Ont |
| Sat Oct 5 1963 | All-Stars 3, Toronto 3 (tie) | Frank Mahovlich, Det | Maple Leaf Gardens | Toronto, Ont |
| Sat Oct 6 1962 | Toronto 4, All-Stars 1 | Eddie Shack, Tor | Maple Leaf Gardens | Toronto, Ont |
| Sat Oct 7 1961 | All-Stars 3, Chicago 1 | None | Chicago Stadium | Chicago, IL |
| Sat Oct 1 1960 | All-Stars 2, Montreal 1 | None | Montreal Forum | Montreal, Que |
| Sat Oct 3 1959 | Montreal 6, All-Stars 1 | None | Montreal Forum | Montreal, Que |
| Sat Oct 4 1958 | Montreal 6, All-Stars 3 | None | Montreal Forum | Montreal, Que |
| Sat Oct 5 1957 | All-Stars 5, Montreal 3 | None | Montreal Forum | Montreal, Que |
| Tue Oct 9 1956 | All-Stars 1, Montreal 1 (tie) | None | Montreal Forum | Montreal, Que |
| Sun Oct 2 1955 | Detroit 3, All-Stars 1 | None | Olympia Stadium | Detroit, MI |
| Sat Oct 2 1954 | All-Stars 2, Detroit 2 (tie) | None | Olympia Stadium | Detroit, MI |
| Sat Oct 3 1953 | All-Stars 3, Montreal 1 | None | Montreal Forum | Montreal, Que |
| Sun Oct 5 1952 | 1st 1, 2nd 1 (tie) | None | Olympia Stadium | Detroit, MI |
| Tue Oct 9 1951 | 1st 2, 2nd 2 (tie) | None | Maple Leaf Gardens | Toronto, Ont |
| Sun Oct 8 1950 | Detroit 7, All-Stars 1 | None | Olympia Stadium | Detroit, MI |
| Mon Oct 10 1949 | All-Stars 3, Toronto 1 | None | Maple Leaf Gardens | Toronto, Ont |
| Wed Nov 3 1948 | All-Stars 3, Toronto 1 | None | Chicago Stadium | Chicago, IL |
| Mon Oct 13 1947 | All-Stars 4, Toronto 3 | None | Maple Leaf Gardens | Toronto, Ont |
| Sun Oct 29 1939 | All-Stars 5, Montreal 2 | None | Montreal Forum | Montreal, Que |
| Wed Nov 3 1937 | All-Stars 6, Montreal 5 | None | Montreal Forum | Montreal, Que |
| Wed Feb 14 1934 | Toronto 7, All-Stars 3 | None | Maple Leaf Gardens | Toronto, Ont |