2021 New York City FC (14-11-9)

17 Apr L at DC United 1- 2  
(0-1-0)
24 Apr W Cincinnati 5- 0  
(1-1-0)
1 May W at Philadelphia 2- 0  
(2-1-0)
8 May T at Orlando 1- 1  
(2-1-1)
15 May T Toronto 1- 1  
(2-1-2)
22 May L Columbus 1- 2  
(2-2-2)
29 May W at Los Angeles FC 2- 1  
(3-2-2)
19 Jun L New England 2- 3  
(3-3-2)
23 Jun W Atlanta 1- 0  
(4-3-2)
27 Jun W DC United 2- 1  
(5-3-2)
7 Jul L at Montreal 1- 2  
(5-4-2)
17 Jul L at Columbus 1- 2  
(5-5-2)
21 Jul W Montreal 1- 0  
(6-5-2)
25 Jul W Orlando 5- 0  
(7-5-2)
30 Jul W Columbus 4- 1  
(8-5-2)
4 Aug T at Chicago 0- 0  
(8-5-3)
7 Aug T at Toronto 2- 2  
(8-5-4)
14 Aug W Miami 2- 0  
(9-5-4)
18 Aug L at Philadelphia 0- 1  
(9-6-4)
28 Aug W New England 2- 0  
(10-6-4)
3 Sep L at Nashville 1- 3  
(10-7-4)
11 Sep L at New England 1- 2  
(10-8-4)
14 Sep T FC Dallas 3- 3  
(10-8-5)
18 Sep W at Cincinnati 2- 1  
(11-8-5)
22 Sep T at NY Red Bulls 1- 1  
(11-8-6)
25 Sep L NY Red Bulls 0- 1  
(11-9-6)
29 Sep L at Chicago 0- 2  
(11-10-6)
3 Oct T Nashville 0- 0  
(11-10-7)
17 Oct L at NY Red Bulls 0- 1  
(11-11-7)
20 Oct T at Atlanta 1- 1  
(11-11-8)
23 Oct W DC United 6- 0  
(12-11-8)
27 Oct W Chicago 1- 0  
(13-11-8)
30 Oct W at Miami 3- 1  
(14-11-8)
7 Nov T at Nashville 1- 1  
(14-11-9)

21 Nov W Atlanta 2- 0  
 
30 Nov W at New England 3- 2 (PK)
 
5 Dec W at Philadelphia 2- 1  
 
11 Dec W at Portland 2- 1 (PK)