 |
|
 |
| MLS Cup championship seasons: none |
| Last MLS Cup championship: none in 30 seasons |
| MetroStars became New York Red Bulls in 2006 |
| Best finish: |
| MetroStars lost to Chicago in Semifinals in 2000 |
| NY Red Bulls lost to Columbus in MLS Cup Finals in 2008 |
| NY Red Bulls lost to LA Galaxy in MLS Cup Finals in 2024 |
| TEAM | SEASON | RECORD | PTS | DIV STAND | PLAYOFFS |
| MetroStars | 1996 | 12-17 | 39 pts | 3rd East Conf | LDC |
| MetroStars | 1997 | 11-19 | 35 pts | 5th East Conf | missed playoffs |
| MetroStars | 1998 | 15-17 | 39 pts | 3rd East Conf | LCbs |
| MetroStars | 1999 | 7-25 | 15 pts | 6th East Conf | missed playoffs |
| MetroStars | 2000 | 17-12-3 | 54 pts | 1st East Div | WDBu LChi |
| MetroStars | 2001 | 13-10-3 | 42 pts | 2nd East Div | LLAG |
| MetroStars | 2002 | 11-15-2 | 35 pts | 4th East Conf | missed playoffs |
| MetroStars | 2003 | 11-10-9 | 42 pts | 3rd East Conf | LNE |
| MetroStars | 2004 | 11-12-7 | 40 pts | 3rd East Conf | LDC |
| MetroStars | 2005 | 12-9-11 | 47 pts | 4th East Conf | LNE |
| NY Red Bulls | 2006 | 9-11-12 | 39 pts | 4th East Conf | LDC |
| NY Red Bulls | 2007 | 12-11-7 | 43 pts | 3rd East Conf | LNE |
| NY Red Bulls | 2008 | 10-11-9 | 39 pts | 5th East Conf | WHou WRSL LCbs |
| NY Red Bulls | 2009 | 5-19-6 | 21 pts | 7th East Conf | missed playoffs |
| NY Red Bulls | 2010 | 15-9-6 | 51 pts | 1st East Conf | LSJ |
| NY Red Bulls | 2011 | 10-8-16 | 46 pts | 5th East Conf | WDal LLAG |
| NY Red Bulls | 2012 | 16-9-9 | 57 pts | 3rd East Conf | bye LDC |
| NY Red Bulls | 2013 | 17-9-8 | 59 pts | 1st East Conf | bye LHou |
| NY Red Bulls | 2014 | 13-10-11 | 50 pts | 4th East Conf | WKC WDC LNE |
| NY Red Bulls | 2015 | 18-10-6 | 60 pts | 1st East Conf | bye WDC LCbs |
| NY Red Bulls | 2016 | 16-9-9 | 57 pts | 1st East Conf | bye LMtl |
| NY Red Bulls | 2017 | 14-12-8 | 50 pts | 6th East Conf | WChi |
| NY Red Bulls | 2018 | 22-7-5 | 71 pts | 1st East Conf | bye WCbs LAtl |
| NY Red Bulls | 2019 | 14-14-6 | 48 pts | 6th East Conf | LPhi |
| NY Red Bulls | 2020 | 9-9-5 | 32 pts | 6th East Conf | LCbs |
| NY Red Bulls | 2021 | 13-12-9 | 48 pts | 7th East Conf | LPhi |
| NY Red Bulls | 2022 | 15-11-8 | 55 pts | 4th East Conf | LCin |
| NY Red Bulls | 2023 | 11-13-10 | 43 pts | 8th East Conf | WCha LCin |
| NY Red Bulls | 2024 | 11-9-14 | 47 pts | 7th East Conf | WCbs WNYF WOrl LLAG |