 |
|
 |
| SEASON | MVP | TEAM | POSITION |
| 2019 | Tommy Grady | Albany Empire | QB |
| 2018 | Tommy Grady | Albany Empire | QB |
| 2017 | Randy Hippeard | Tampa Bay Storm | QB |
| 2016 | Nick Davila | Arizona Rattlers | QB |
| 2015 | Dan Raudabaugh | Philadelphia Soul | QB |
| 2014 | Nick Davila | Arizona Rattlers | QB |
| 2013 | Erik Meyer | Spokane Shock | QB |
| 2012 | Tommy Grady | Utah Blaze | QB |
| 2011 | Nick Davila | Arizona Rattlers | QB |
| 2010 Off 2010 Def |
Chris Griesen Greg White |
Milwaukee Iron Orlando Predators |
QB DL |
| 2008 Off 2008 Def |
Chris Jackson Dennison Robinson |
Philadelphia Soul Chicago Rush |
WR WR/DB |
| 2007 Off 2007 Def |
Siaha Burley Greg White |
Utah Blaze Orlando Predators |
WR DL |
| 2006 Off 2006 Def |
Damian Harrell Jerald Brown |
Colorado Crush Columbus Destroyers |
WR DB |
| 2005 Off 2005 Def |
Damian Harrell Silas Demary |
Colorado Crush Los Angeles Avengers |
WR DL |
| 2004 Off 2004 Def |
Marcus Nash Kenny McEntyre |
Las Vegas Gladiators Orlando Predators |
OS DS |
| 2003 Off 2003 Def |
Chris Jackson Clevan Thomas |
Los Angeles Avengers San Jose SaberCats |
OS DS |
| 2002 Off 2002 Def |
Mark Grieb Clevan Thomas |
San Jose SaberCats San Jose SaberCats |
QB DS |
| 2001 Off 2001 Def |
Aaron Garcia Kenny McEntyre |
New York Dragons Orlando Predators |
QB DS |
| 2000 Off 2000 Def |
Mike Horacek Kenny McEntyre |
Iowa Barnstormers Orlando Predators |
OS DS |
| 1999 Off 1999 Def |
Eddie Brown James Baron |
Albany Firebirds Nashville Kats (1st) |
OS DL |
| 1998 Off 1998 Def |
Calvin Schexnayder Johnnie Harris |
Arizona Rattlers Tampa Bay Storm |
WR DL |
| 1997 Off 1997 Def |
Barry Wagner Tracey Perkins |
Orlando Predators Tampa Bay Storm |
WR/LB WR/DB |
| 1996 Off 1996 Def |
Eddie Brown David McLeod |
Albany Firebirds Albany Firebirds |
OS WR/DB |
| 1995 | Barry Wagner | Orlando Predators | WR/DB |
| 1994 | Eddie Brown | Albany Firebirds | OS |
| 1993 | Hunkie Cooper | Arizona Rattlers | OS |
| 1992 | Jay Gruden | Tampa Bay Storm | QB |
| 1991 | George LaFrance | Detroit Drive | OS |
| 1990 | Art Schlichter | Detroit Drive | QB |
| 1989 | George LaFrance | Detroit Drive | WR/DB |
| 1988 | Ben Bennett | Chicago Bruisers | QB |
| 1987 | Russell Hairston | Pittsburgh Gladiators | WR/DB |