 |
|
 |
| Arena Bowl championship seasons: none |
| Last Arena Bowl championship: none in 11 seasons |
| Buffalo Destroyers became Columbus Destroyers in 2004 |
| Best finish (by location): |
| Buffalo lost to Arizona in AFL 1st Round in 2000 season |
| Buffalo lost to Orlando in AFL 1st Round in 2002 season |
| Columbus lost to San Jose in Arena Bowl in 2007 season |
| TEAM | SEASON | RECORD | PERC | DIV STAND | CNF STAND | PLAYOFFS |
| Buffalo | 1999 | 1-13 | .071 | 4th Eastern | 8th National | missed playoffs |
| Buffalo | 2000 | 5-9 | .357 | 3rd Eastern | 6th National | LAri |
| Buffalo | 2001 | 6-8 | .429 | 4th Eastern | T7th National | missed playoffs |
| Buffalo | 2002 | 6-8 | .429 | 2nd Eastern | 5th National | LOrl |
| Buffalo | 2003 | 5-11 | .312 | 4th Eastern | 7th National | missed playoffs |
| Columbus | 2004 | 6-10 | .375 | 4th Eastern | T7th National | missed playoffs |
| Columbus | 2005 | 2-14 | .125 | 4th Eastern | 9th National | missed playoffs |
| Columbus | 2006 | 8-8 | .500 | 4th Eastern | 7th National | missed playoffs |
| Columbus | 2007 | 7-9 | .438 | 3rd Eastern | 6th National | WTB WDlD WGeo LSJ |
| Columbus | 2008 | 3-13 | .188 | 5rd Eastern | 9th National | missed playoffs |
| Columbus | 2019 | 1-11 | .083 | 6th Arena | missed playoffs |