 |
|
 |
| SEASON | CHAMP | SECOND | MVP |
| 2019 | Albany Empire | Philadelphia Soul | Tommy Grady, QB, Alb |
| 2018 | Washington Valor | Baltimore Brigade | Arvell Nelson, QB, Wsh |
| 2017 | Philadelphia Soul | Tampa Bay Storm | Off: Darius Prince, WR, Phi Def: James Romain, DB, Phi |
| 2016 | Philadelphia Soul | Arizona Rattlers | Off: Maurice Purify, WR, Ari Def: Tracy Belton, DB, Phi |
| 2015 | San Jose SaberCats | Jacksonville Sharks | Off: Erik Meyer, QB, SJ Def: David Hyland, DB, SJ |
| 2014 | Arizona Rattlers | Cleveland Gladiators | Off: Nick Davila, QB, Ari Def: Cliff Dukes, DE, Ari |
| 2013 | Arizona Rattlers | Philadelphia Soul | Off: Rod Windsor, WR, Ari Def: Virgil Gray, DB, Ari |
| 2012 | Arizona Rattlers | Philadelphia Soul | Off: Nick Davila, QB, Ari Def: Arkeith Brown, DB, Ari |
| 2011 | Jacksonville Sharks | Arizona Rattlers | Off: Chris Jackson, WR, Ari Def: Micheaux Robinson, DB, Jac |
| 2010 | Spokane Shock | Tampa Bay Storm | Off: Markee White, WR, Spo Def: Jeremy Geathers, DL, Spo |
| 2008 | Philadelphia Soul | San Jose SaberCats | Off: Chris Jackson, WR, Phi Def: Gabe Nyenhuis, DL, Phi |
| 2007 | San Jose SaberCats | Columbus Destroyers | Off: Mark Grieb, QB, SJ Def: Omarr Smith, DB, SJ |
| 2006 | Chicago Rush | Orlando Predators | Off: Matt D'Orazio, QB, Chi Def: Dennison Robinson, DB, Chi |
| 2005 | Colorado Crush | Georgia Force | Off: Willis Marshall, WR/DB, Col Def: Ahmad Hawkins, WR/DB, Col |
| 2004 | San Jose SaberCats | Arizona Rattlers | Off: Mark Grieb, QB, SJ Def: Ricky Parker, DS, Ari |
| 2003 | Tampa Bay Storm | Arizona Rattlers | Lawrence Samuels, WR/LB, TB |
| 2002 | San Jose SaberCats | Arizona Rattlers | John Dutton, QB, SJ |
| 2001 | Grand Rapids Rampage | Nashville Kats (1st) | Terrill Shaw, OS, GR |
| 2000 | Orlando Predators | Nashville Kats (1st) | Connell Maynor, QB, Orl |
| 1999 | Albany Firebirds | Orlando Predators | Eddie Brown, OS, Alb |
| 1998 | Orlando Predators | Tampa Bay Storm | Rick Hamilton, FB/LB, Orl |
| 1997 | Arizona Rattlers | Iowa Barnstormers | Donnie Davis, QB, Ari |
| 1996 | Tampa Bay Storm | Iowa Barnstormers | Stevie Thomas, WR/LB, TB |
| 1995 | Tampa Bay Storm | Orlando Predators | George LaFrance, OS, TB |
| 1994 | Arizona Rattlers | Orlando Predators | Sherdrick Bonner, QB, Ari |
| 1993 | Tampa Bay Storm | Detroit Drive | Jay Gruden, QB, TB |
| 1992 | Detroit Drive | Orlando Predators | George LaFrance, OS, Det |
| 1991 | Tampa Bay Storm | Detroit Drive | Stevie Thomas, WR/LB, TB |
| 1990 | Detroit Drive | Dallas Texans | Art Schlichter, QB, Det |
| 1989 | Detroit Drive | Pittsburgh Gladiators | George LaFrance, WR/DB, Det |
| 1988 | Detroit Drive | Chicago Bruisers | Steve Griffin, WR/DB, Det |
| 1987 | Denver Dynamite | Pittsburgh Gladiators | Gary Mullen, WR/DB, Den |