1917 Colgate (4-2) Independent

Wk 5 Sat 13 Oct W Bucknell 24- 0   (1-0)
Wk 6 Sat 20 Oct W at Cornell 20- 0   (2-0)
Wk 7 Sat 27 Oct L at Brown 6- 7   (2-1)
Wk 8 Sat 3 Nov W vs Holy Cross 21- 0   (3-1)
Wk 9 Sat 10 Nov W St Bonaventure 40- 6   (4-1)
Wk 10 Sat 17 Nov L at Syracuse 7- 27   (4-2)