| 1960 |
| |
| 1. Minnesota |
| 2. Mississippi |
| 3. Iowa |
| 4. Navy |
| 5. Missouri |
| 6. Washington |
| 7. Arkansas |
| 8. Ohio St |
| 9. Alabama |
| 10. Duke |
| 11. Kansas |
| 12. Baylor |
| 13. Auburn |
| 14. Yale |
| 15. Michigan St |
| 16. Penn St |
| 17. New Mexico St |
| 18. Florida |
| 19. Syracuse |
| Purdue |
|
| 1961 |
|
| 1. Alabama |
| 2. Ohio St |
| 3. Texas |
| 4. LSU |
| 5. Mississippi |
| 6. Minnesota |
| 7. Colorado |
| 8. Michigan St |
| 9. Arkansas |
| 10. Utah St |
| 11. Missouri |
| 12. Purdue |
| 13. Georgia Tech |
| 14. Syracuse |
| 15. Rutgers |
| 16. UCLA |
| 17. Rice |
| Penn St |
| Arizona |
| 20. Duke |
|
| 1962 |
|
| 1. USC |
| 2. Wisconsin |
| 3. Mississippi |
| 4. Texas |
| 5. Alabama |
| 6. Arkansas |
| 7. LSU |
| 8. Oklahoma |
| 9. Penn St |
| 10. Minnesota |
|
| 1963 |
|
| 1. Texas |
| 2. Navy |
| 3. Illinois |
| 4. Pittsburgh |
| 5. Auburn |
| 6. Nebraska |
| 7. Mississippi |
| 8. Alabama |
| 9. Oklahoma |
| 10. Michigan St |
|
| 1964 |
| |
| 1. Alabama |
| 2. Arkansas |
| 3. Notre Dame |
| 4. Michigan |
| 5. Texas |
| 6. Nebraska |
| 7. LSU |
| 8. Oregon St |
| 9. Ohio St |
| 10. USC |
|
